Table 1

General characteristics of included studies

CharacteristicNo. (%) (95% CI, %) (n=476)
Publication language
 Chinese258 (54.2) (49.7 to 58.6)
 English218 (45.8) (41.4 to 50.2)
Location of the study
 Multicountry10 (2.1) (1.1 to 3.8)
 China397 (83.4) (79.8 to 86.5)
 Other countries (eg, USA, Iran, Korea)69 (14.5) (11.6 to 17.9)
Type of study centre
 Single-centre180 (37.8) (33.6 to 42.3)
 Multicentre296 (62.2) (57.7 to 66.4)
Acupuncture type
 Conventional acupuncture276 (58.0) (53.5 to 62.3)
 Electroacupuncture163 (34.2) (30.1 to 38.6)
 Small needle-knife12 (2.5) (1.4 to 4.4)
 Others25 (5.3) (3.6 to 7.6)
Disease system
 Nervous system166 (34.9) (30.7 to 39.3)
 Motor system68 (14.3) (11.4 to 17.7)
 Digestive system61 (12.8) (10.1 to 16.1)
 Other system181 (38.0) (33.8 to 42.5)
Source of funding
 Institutional funding369 (77.5) (73.6 to 81.0)
 Individual funding1 (0.2) (0.0 to 1.2)
 Mixed funding1 (0.2) (0.0 to 1.2)
 None105 (22.1) (18.6 to 26.0)
Conflict of interest
 Declared of interest165 (34.7) (30.5 to 39.0)
 Not mention311 (65.3) (61.0 to 69.5)
Registration
 Prospective registration127 (26.7) (22.9 to 30.8)
 Retrospective registration41 (8.6) (6.4 to 11.5)
 Unregistered308 (64.7) (60.3 to 68.9)
Journal Impact Factor, median (25th, 75th)
Chinese journals2.5 (1.3, 4.0)
English journals2.4 (1.4, 3.0)
Sample size, median, (25th, 75th)72 (60, 100)